Jean Plaidy Archive

The Reluctant Queen by Jean Plaidy

Posted June 8, 2012 By dorolerium

Title: The Reluctant Queen
Author: Jean Plaidy
Publisher: Three Rivers Press
Genre: Historical Fiction
Pages: 464
How I Read It: Kindle edition purchased by me

Synopsis: In 1470, a reluctant Lady Anne Neville is betrothed by her father, the politically ambitious Earl of Warwick, to Edward, Prince of Wales, a Lancaster. A gentle yet fiercely intelligent woman, Anne has already given her heart to the younger brother of the Yorkist King, Richard, Duke of Gloucester.

Unable to oppose her father’s will, she finds herself in line for the throne of England—an obligation that she does not want. Yet fate intervenes when Edward is killed at the Battle of Tewkesbury. Anne suddenly finds herself free to marry the man she loves—and who loves her in return.

The ceremony is held at Westminster Abbey, and the duke and duchess make a happy home at Middleham Castle, where both spent much of their childhood. Their life is idyllic, until the reigning king dies and a whirlwind of dynastic maneuvering leads to his children being declared illegitimate. Richard inherits the throne as King Richard III, and Anne is crowned queen consort, a destiny she thought she had successfully avoided.

Her husband’s reign lasts two years, two months, and two days—and in that short time Anne witnesses the true toll that wearing the crown takes on Richard, the last king from the House of York.

*Synopsis taken from Goodreads

My Review: Many history lovers are familiar with the general story of Richard III, but less so with his queen consort, Anne Neville.  As their lives are quite intertwined from the beginning, this story really follows the two of them from early childhood through their adulthood, marriage, and beyond.

The book talks a lot about the political climate during this time in British history – we cover threats from the Lancastrians, to the York reign, back to plots against the Yorkists from a variety of individuals.  It’s a wonder that Richard was even able to hold onto the throne for as long as he was, given the fact that his beloved brother, Edward IV, had so many problems despite his popularity.

History does not remember Richard III fondly, there is quite a bit of mystery surrounding how he came to the throne and what really happened to the York princes in the tower.  While Plaidy doesn’t solve that mystery for us, she does a great job of painting Richard in a more sympathetic light, and gives a more plausible explanation for the events that occur during the time he ascended to the throne.

Like many young women in the same timeframe, Anne is largely a victim of whatever the men in her life want her to do.  Plaidy does a great job of showing how Anne likely did her best to deal with the situations at hand.  I especially liked that Margaret of Anjou was softened up a bit, with a hesitant friendship between her and Anne during the time they spend together.

I’m a huge fan of Jean Plaidy as a writer, I consider her to be one of the best historical fiction authors out there, and this book exemplifies why I believe this.  She is excellent at telling the “other side” of the story, and I’ll never look at Richard III in the same way again.

Read this book if: I think any fan of Plaidy or War of the Roses historical fiction will enjoy this one.

My Rating: 4/5 – Borderline amazing!

Madonna of the Seven Hills by Jean Plaidy

Posted July 1, 2011 By dorolerium

Synopsis: Fifteenth-century Rome: The Borgia family is on the rise. Lucrezia’s father, Pope Alexander VI, places his illegitimate daughter and her only brothers, Cesare, Giovanni, and Goffredo, in the jeweled splendor—and scandal—of his court. From the Pope’s affairs with adolescent girls to Cesare’s dangerous jealousy of anyone who inspires Lucrezia’s affections to the ominous birth of a child conceived in secret, no Borgia can elude infamy.

Young Lucrezia gradually accepts her fate as she comes to terms with the delicate nature of her relationships with her father and brothers. The unbreakable bond she shares with them both exhilarates and terrifies her as her innocence begins to fade. Soon she will understand that her family’s love pales next to their quest for power and that she herself is the greatest tool in their political arsenal.

From the inimitable pen of Jean Plaidy, this family’s epic legend is replete with passion, intrigue, and murder—and it’s only the beginning.

My Review: I didn’t know much about the Borgia’s before reading this, and I had such a great time learning about them as I was reading this!  Just like any other book by Plaidy, you can always count on her to tell a story in such an interesting way that you don’t even realize it’s based on history.

The Borgia’s are such an interesting family, I loved the dynamic Plaidy portrayed between the brothers and Lucrezia, as well as their father, who loves them more than anything in the world.  Alexander is just as conniving as any King you’ve read about in any historical piece, politicking his way to the top of the Church and placing his children in strategic positions both in the church and around the rest of Italy.

Poor Lucrezia is stuck in the middle of everything, a pawn in everyone’s game, used for whatever suits Alexander and to a lesser extent, her brothers.  It makes me feel so bad for all the women during this time period, they have so little choice and get lucky every now and then to have an understanding husband once they’re married.  Lucrezia is lucky to have a father who protects her from everyone but her own family, which is both good and bad considering how manipulative her brothers can be.

I really enjoyed this story and since it’s the first of a two books about the Borgias, I’ll definitely be reading the second one.  I think this is a great introduction to the Borgia family, shining a great light on Lucrezia and showing us fabulous insight into the her family and the time period.  I’d recommend this book to anyone who enjoys historical fiction, or anything set in Italy during this time frame.

Read this book if: You like Jean Plaidy, historical fiction, or the Borgia family.

My Rating: 4/5 – Borderline Amazing!

The Rose Without a Thorn by Jean Plaidy

Posted June 3, 2011 By dorolerium

Synopsis: From the pen of legendary historical novelist Jean Plaidy comes an unforgettable true story of royalty, passion, and innocence lost.

Born into an impoverished branch of the noble Howard family, young Katherine is plucked from her home to live with her grandmother, the Duchess of Norfolk. The innocent girl quickly learns that her grandmother’s puritanism is not shared by Katherine’s free-spirited cousins, with whom she lives. Beautiful and impressionable, Katherine becomes involved in two ill-fated love affairs before her sixteenth birthday. Like her cousin Anne Boleyn, she leaves her grandmother’s home to become a lady-in-waiting at the court of Henry VIII. The royal palaces are exciting to a young girl from the country, and Katherine finds that her duties there allow her to be near her handsome cousin, Thomas Culpepper, whom she has loved since childhood.

But when Katherine catches the eye of the aging and unhappily married king, she is forced to abandon her plans for a life with Thomas and marry King Henry. Overwhelmed by the change in her fortunes, bewildered and flattered by the adoration of her husband, Katherine is dazzled by the royal life. But her bliss is short-lived as rumors of her wayward past come back to haunt her, and Katherine’s destiny takes another, deadly, turn.

My Review: I love Jean Plaidy, I’ve never made any secret of that fact, and I found that she does a fabulous job of articulating what I’ve always thought about Katherine Howard, Henri VIII’s ill fated fifth wife.  The writing is as masterful as always, and even if you’re familiar with the tale of Katherine Howard, I think you’ll find yourself wrapped up in this book.  The story starts out with Katherine talking to her friend, the scribe, and it is all presented as the story she is telling to the scribe in the days leading up to her death.

Katherine is portrayed as a mostly thoughtless girl who lives entirely for the present, which is totally how I’ve always thought of her.  Time and time again she says something along the lines of “why didn’t I think about what this would mean for the future?”  And also mentions how she should have thought more about how her actions were so in line with what had sent her cousin, Anne Boleyn, to the scaffold.  At one point, Katherine even says that while she believed her cousin to be innocent, she knew she herself was not.

Although this story is not a new one to me, it was presented in a new way in that Katherine knew her actions were dangerous and she gave in to them heedless of the consequences.  She was almost noble at times, wanting to protect Thomas Culpepper as much as she could and refraining from saying anything that would implicate him in any way.  With that in mind, it’s very sad to me that she did what she could to protect him, but didn’t seem to be trying to protect Francis Derehem in any way.  I mean, what if she had told them that there was a pre-contract?  Would it have saved all their lives?

I loved that Plaidy shows Katherine’s regrets, even though some of them may be misplaced, and in her way she even tries to make up for her past indiscretions.  What is extra interesting to me is that if Katherine lived in today’s society, she would have been a pretty normal girl.  She just had the misfortune of being born in the wrong time, and catching the eye of the wrong man.

Read this book if: On the whole, this is a fantastic book and I definitely recommend picking it up.  I think any fan of Plaidy or Tudor England will really enjoy it.

My Rating: 3.5/5 – Two thumbs up, fine holiday fun!

Murder Most Royal by Jean Plaidy

Posted June 19, 2010 By dorolerium

Murder Most Royal

Synopsis: In the court of Henry VIII, it was dangerous for a woman to catch the king’s eye.  Anne Boleyn and Catherine Howard were cousins.  Both were beautiful women, though very different in temperament.  They each learned that Henry’s passion was all-consuming – and fickle.

Sophisticated Anne Boleyn, raised in the decadent court of France, was in love with another man when King Henry claimed her as his own.  Being his mistress gave her a position of power; being his queen put her life in jeopardy.  Her younger cousin, Catherine Howeard, was only fifteen when she was swept into the circle of King Henry.  Her innocence attracted him, but a past mistake was destined to haunt her.

Painted in the rich colors of Tudor England, Murder Most Royal is a page turning journey into the lives of two of the wives of the tempestuous Henry VIII.

My Review: Jean Plaidy once again works her magic in this lovely tale of the two most ill fated queens married to Henry VIII.  If you are a Tudor fan, and have never read anything by Plaidy, this is definitely a great one to start with.  I dreaded the times when I was forced to put it down, I would have happily read the book in one sitting if I had the chance.

I loved the way Plaidy mixed the lives of Anne and Catherine, making potential guesses as to their interaction and what they may have thought of each other, especially with them not knowing until the end that they would share the same fate.

I will never cease to be fascinated with Anne Boleyn, and no matter how many times I read something about her, I always hope her story will end differently.  I feel so much for this woman, and imagine how horrible it would have been to be torn away from your love, swept up in the extravagance of the Tudor Court.

Even Catherine is painted in a more sympathetic life than I’ve seen her in previously – you get to see her whole life, from being a young child of a year or so to her death.  I found myself feeling how unfair her life must have been – she wanted nothing more than to be happy, and simply had the misfortune of marrying a mad man.

Knowing what happens in the end for both of these women gives an interesting light to peripheral characters, especially Jane Rochford, who played such a crucial role in the fate of them all.  For me, history is filled with “what if’s”, and Jane’s actions have perhaps more what if’s than that of any other.

I cannot say enough good about this story, and I strongly encourage everyone to read it at they’re first chance!

Read this book if: You like Anne Boleyn, Catherine Howard, or books about the Tudor court.  It really is a great read!

Loyal in Love by Jean Plaidy

Posted April 17, 2010 By dorolerium

Loyal in Love

*Image provided by Good Reads

Synopsis: The daughter of Henry IV of France, Princess Henrietta Maria, becomes a pawn in a political strategy to stabilize relations between two countries when her father marries her to Charles I of England. Sent abroad, she finds herself living in a Protestant country that views her own faith—Catholicism—with deep suspicion. Yet her new husband is a man of principle and integrity, and Henrietta and Charles fall deeply in love. Henrietta is passionate about her faith, however, and soon politically powerful people, namely Oliver Cromwell and his Puritans, turn her loyalty to her religion into a focal point for civil war. As the royal couple watch the fall of Thomas Wentworth, first Earl of Strafford, the rise of Puritanism, and Englishmen fight Englishmen, they are undeterred in their dedication to each other and in their belief in the divine rights of king and queen—even as spies lurk in their very own household. Loyal in Love offers an inside look at an unforgettable time in England’s history and at the life of a queen whose story of devotion and bravery has gone untold for too long.

Review: I decided to try and switch things up a bit and read more about another royal family I’m interested in – the Stuarts. A book like this always makes me wish I could have known the characters during their actual life times; to have conversations with them and try to understand what is going on in their heads. I spent much of this book being both fascinated and frustrated by Henrietta at the same time. I cannot remember the last time I wished I could just take a main characters face in both my hands and ask them to at least try to think about something other than themselves.

Henrietta seems, at times, to be a religious zealot, and I felt through much of the book that the only time she made any consideration for the people of England was when she was trying to convert them to Catholicism. It was amazing to see the level of selfishness from a person who should have been concerned for the wellfare of an entire country.

Despite my love/hate relationship with Henrietta, I did like the book and found it very interesting to see the relationship between her and Charles grow from a pretty rocky situation, to a loving, beautiful marriage. It was wonderful to read about a happy and loyal marriage, especially knowing that so many kings had numerous mistresses…and sometimes numerous wives!

I will say that I don’t think this is necessarily a good book to start out with if you don’t know anything about the Stuarts. I was curious to see the roots of Catholicism in their family, knowing that it causes so much strife later on. Nonetheless, Jean Plaidy does not disappoint. The writing was as fantastic as you would expect, and I really felt as though I was there with these people, as frustrating as I found them to be at times.

Read this book if: You like Jean Plaidy, or are interested in reading historical fiction about the Stuarts.  I put Henrietta on par with Katherine Howard for level of irritation prompted by reading about them ;)

The King’s Confidante by Jean Plaidy

Posted March 27, 2010 By dorolerium

ConfidanteSynopsis: An English lawyer and statesman, Sir Thomas More was a kind father who put as much emphasis on educating his daughters as on his son, declaring that women were just as intelligent as men.  His favorite daughter, Meg, is the heroine of this novel in which we witness the everyday lives of people in Tudor England.  Plaidy takes readers into a world far removed from the grandeur of the courts, into the home of a simple family and a caring father who only wants to do what is morally best – not just for his family, but for England.

As secretary and personal adviser to King Henry VIII, More becomes increasingly influential in the government, welcoming foreign diplomats, drafting official documents, and serving as liaison between the king and the Archbishop of York.  His own household stands in startling contrast to the licentious Tudor court, but as lorg chencellor he gains recognition and becomes indispensable to the king.  More’s love of faith surpasses his duty to the crown, and his refusal to accept King Henry VIII’s claim to be supreme head of the Church of England ends his political career…and leads to his trial for treason.

My Review: Even before I developed my obsession with Tudor England, I had a keen interest in Sir Thomas More.  He’s always been a historical figure that stood out to me – someone that dared to openly defy King Henry VIII, fully knowing the consequences of doing so?  That’s an admirable and curious man in my book.  So when I realized that Plaidy, one of my favorite historical authors, wrote a book focusing on More’s life, I had to read it.

Although the book has More’s eldest daughter, Meg, as the heroine, I was pleasantly surprised to see that it really was about Thomas himself more than anything else.  His story is a tragic one as it is, but to see how great a man he really was, how sympathetic and loveable he remained throughout, made it even harder to read of his inevitable death.  I’m not embarrassed to admit that it brought me to tears, even though I knew it was coming.

At the beginning of the book, we are still in King Henry VII’s reign, and I especially liked the contrast between his reaction to Thomas More and Henry VIII’s.  While Henry VII looked at More as essentially a nuisance who got in his way, Henry VIII viewed him as a friend and confidante in spite of their differences.  Yet all the while, I kept thinking “If only Thomas had made one different choice…”, even though we all know that wouldn’t have really made a difference in the end anyway.  Thomas More was a great mind of his time, who would likely have attracted the attention of the King regardless of whether he had chosen a different path for his life.  Despite his own reluctance to ascend to the positions he attained, he was simply destined for greater things, albeit for a short while.

I also very much liked the focus by More on educating his daughters, it’s rare to see a man of this time period who actually believed women were worth more than their ability to bear children.  In reading the book, you could really feel the love he felt for Meg, and the overall interest he had in helping the women in his life acheive the same level of education as the men.

This book also provides a great look at Tudor life from a semi-outside perspective.  Yes, More was on the Privy Council, but he tries as much as he can to live a normal life, and I find it very interesting to see what things were like for a closer to average person in Tudor England.  I highly recommend it to anyone interested in this period of history, especially since it gives you both the look at court life and shows the effects that court can have on those reluctant to be a part of it.

Read this book if: You like Tudor novels, Jean Plaidy, or Thomas More.  Or just read it because it’s interesting!!!

The Sixth Wife by Jean Plaidy

Posted June 12, 2009 By dorolerium

I don’t know why I didn’t start reading Jean Plaidy books much earlier.  I love the tales she weaves, the way she really seems to identify with these historical people.

Going into this book, I didn’t know a whole lot about Katherine Parr, and to an extent, I still feel like I don’t.  I don’t think this is any fault of the author, I really think it’s simply because there isn’t a whole lot of information about Katherine Parr out there.  We know so little about her, other than Henry was planning to rid himself of her but died before he could.

Despite the fact that this story is surrounding court and all that goes along with that, I really felt like there was a lot more to it than that.  The religious turmoil of this time in history is very fascinating, and I really feel like anyone who thinks these books are nothing but court intrigue simply hasn’t invested enough time to learn more about the whole thing.

I think my favorite part was the tale of Anne Askew.  Her story is just so sad and interesting at the same time – the only woman to be tortured in the tower!  It’s really interesting to me that someone like her, who had no training against torture, could still withstand it and not give up any names.  Maybe she didn’t know anyone else to give up, but I think it’s more likely that she simply was that strong and protected everyone else she knew who would be considered guilty of preaching the new learning.

All the stories interweaved was very interesting, it can be easy to forget how…related…everyone was back then.  I mean, the talk of Edward marrying Jane Grey when you know they’re related, it’s just bizarre.  But yet, so interesting that no one thinks twice about it, they embrace it, in fact.  What could be better than someone with two royal blooded parents!

I’ll definitely continue to read Jean Plaidy’s books, and invest more time in the books she has written under other names as well.

Read this book if: You want to know more about Katherine Parr, what life was like for a woman who knew that two of Henry’s wives lost their lives essentially for political reasons.  That she couldn’t say no, yet knew it might mean her death to say yes.  All very interesting stuff.

Lady in the Tower by Jean Plaidy

Posted October 21, 2008 By dorolerium

I failed to mention prior to departure that I was spending a week at Disney World in Orlando, Florida. No time for blogging, but plenty of time for reading. In fact, I was only about half way through this book at the start of the trip and finished it on the first flight from Salt Lake to Atlanta. It made the flight go by fast! I had packed another book, but it was in my checked luggage since I figured I wouldn’t be finishing half a book in those few hours. Which means that in the Atlanta airport I bought another book because no way was I hopping on a 2 hour flight without a book to read!

Anyway, I was glad to get a new to me perspective on Anne Boleyn. Everything I had read recently, even the book I, Elizabeth was kind of negative about Anne. I think I’ve mentioned this before, but I consider her to be a really sympathetic character and I’ve always felt like everything that happened to her was a real shame. It amazes me when I realize how little so many people know about this woman who vastly changed the course of history. Her impact on what happened in England is ginormous – could any of us imagine an England without Elizabeth I in its history? How different would things have been if this one woman had simply had a male child survive?

I was pretty happy with the book, there were only a few minor inaccuracies that bothered me. Some things just don’t make any sense at all – there’s no evidence to support that Elizabeth Howard Boleyn (Anne’s mother) died when Anne was a young child. In fact, she outlived both Anne and George due to their misfortune. So I don’t understand when an author takes the liberty of having a step mother from the time Anne is 9 or whatever in the book. It really just didn’t make any sense, knowing the truth of the situation.

Other things, however, make a little more sense, even if I don’t like them. I’m not a huge fan of propagating the idea that Anne had any kind of birth defect, in this case a sixth fingernail and a strange mole on her neck. Knowing how defects like this were viewed during this period of history, I’ve always found it difficult to believe that if it were true, Henry would have ever married her. I think the more likely explanation for these stories was a desire to say that she was in fact a witch and enchanted Henry, so of course she had these defects that would have either marked her as such or planted the idea in his head. My guess is she was perfectly normal and people just wanted to believe so badly that something was wrong with her, so they went with it.

I think I will always feel like Anne Boleyn’s story is a tragic one and something that will always fascinate me. I can never read enough about her, even when people are painting her as an awful person with nothing but ambition. I loved how throughout the book she emphasized that she didn’t love Henry, but she felt like he had stolen her one love from her so she might as well aim as high as she could. Although that’s definitely ambition to an extent, I think I can sympathize because undoubtedly in that time, knowing you would be unlikely to be married to someone you loved, you might as well take the king if you can get him. I genuinely feel that to an extent, she didn’t have a choice. Her only option would have been to get married to someone else or actually claim she had a precontract with Henry Percy or Thomas Wyatt, and even those things wouldn’t guarantee that you’d stop Henry VIII.

When you look at it from the perspective that I generally do, that Henry was a little insane himself and would stop at nothing to get what he wanted, Anne really had no other choice. What is to say that if there had been an impediment to her marriage with Henry he wouldn’t have just eliminated it by imprisoning and killing whoever that other man was? I think it’s well within the things he would have done to get what he wanted. So really, Anne was doomed from the start and things were likely set in motion the moment he laid eyes on her. Sure, she could have done things along the way to possibly give herself an out that didn’t involve beheading, but I really feel like she was not in control of the situation and was at the mercy of much more powerful men.

Read this book if: You like Anne Boleyn and want to see a sympathetic take on her life. She is not vilified in this novel at all and I think it’s rather refreshing. Even if you don’t like Anne Boleyn, or don’t know who she is, read the book to see if you get a new perspective on her. I can guarantee it’s different from the one you’ll see in The Other Boleyn Girl.