Feb 11

Wither by Lauren DeStefano

Synopsis: In the not-too-distant future, because of genetic engineering, every human is a ticking time bomb…

Males only live to age twenty-five, and females only live to age twenty.  To keep the population from dying out, girls are kidnapped and sold into polygamous marriages.

When sixteen-year-old Rhine is taken, she enters a world of wealth and privilege that both entices and terrifies her.  She has everything she ever wanted — except freedom.  With the help of Gabriel, a servant Rhine is growing dangerously attracted to, Rhine attempts to escape before it is too late.

My Review: This book opens with a rather terrifying scene, and it doesn’t really stop throughout the entire story.  And I will admit that I have mixed feelings about it – not because it’s bad, but because it’s a future I can honestly see humanity succumbing to.  The book itself is pretty good, it makes me think, and I don’t think I’ll ever complain about that.

I haven’t really read other dystopian novels, frankly I’m not terribly interested in seeing the wretchedness I know we as people are capable of, and that I believe we are only a few generations away from.  In this world, women seem to mostly be viewed as disposable, valued only for their ability to bear children – which sounds sadly like the sort of life women had in the not so distant past.

The most frightening part of this, to me, is that I can very much see this genuinely happening if we were to face extinction as a race.  As women, we have been looked on in this light for so much of our history, and I simply don’t trust men to continue recognizing us as they have if they don’t feel forced into it.  And in a scenario where the human race is dying out, I fear the child bearing sex would be somewhat forced to do as the men want.

Much of this story also left me thinking about mortality in general, as it’s a little depressing to read about this type of world, where I and most of the people I care about would have been well expired.  It’s simply sad to think of these lives ending before they’ve really had the chance to live.  I think of how my own life has improved so much since I was twenty, and I mourn for these fictional girls who never have that shot.

All of that aside, our main character Rhine is a character I have a difficult time understanding.  Maybe it’s a simplistic way for me to look at things, but wouldn’t it be better for Rhine to just tell someone in power about the life she had before, and ask them to look for her brother?  If you know you’re dying in four years, wouldn’t you rather get your loved ones in your new found safer, wealthier situation?  The world she comes from is described as such a bleak situation that I can’t really imagine myself wanting to go back to it.

However, there are two more books in this series, and I am pretty curious to see what will happen next, what this future really does hold.  Will there be a cure for the virus?  Will Rhine find her way back to the life she wants?  And will that life be everything she hoped it would be?

Read this book if: You’re interested in dystopian or YA novels.  I did enjoy this book and I want to see more of it!

My Rating: 4/5 – Borderline Amazing!

Full Disclosure: I received this book for free from the publisher, Simon & Schuster Children’s Publishing.  This has not affected my review in any way.  I was likewise not compensated for this review.


Skip to comment form

  1. starlakity

    this is right up my alley! :) i pre-ordered for the kindle. i’ll have it on 3/22!

    1. dorolerium

      Oh good! I’ll be looking forward to seeing what you think of it :) I quite enjoyed it!

  2. Chrystal

    I am looking forward to this one as well. I love YA and dystopian novels. I’ve had my eye on this book for some time. I love the cover.

    It is intersting to think that I am older than the oldest age that people live until in this book. It’s sad to think that people will not see everything they are meant to see or do in life… because they will have passed on at such a young age. I cannot imagine a life like that.

    1. dorolerium

      It really made me think about how old I am in comparison to these characters too, and how sad their lives must be. You’ll have to let me know what you think when you read it!

      And yes, the cover is beautiful :)

      1. Chrystal

        As soon as I read it I will have a post up on my blog about it. I’ll try to remember to post about it on LJ too. :)

        1. dorolerium

          I always forget to post anything on LJ about the books I’m reading. But you’re in my google reader, so I’ll see it when you do read it :)

  3. Christina T

    Great review! I liked Wither but found parts of it disturbing to read about (which is normal for the genre I guess). I am looking forward to the next book too to find out what happens.

    1. dorolerium

      Yes, there were bits to me that were really difficult to read, especially the stuff that takes place in the basement. It’s such an interesting genre, but one that really scares me to a large extent as well. The next book should be interesting!

Comments have been disabled.